Hezekiah Shaffer was a quiet man, they said. He had fought bravely and suffered wounds in the Civil War. After the war, he returned home to Franklin County and married Eliza Snyder. They lived near St. Thomas. But he was never quite the same after the war. In April of 1878, he was convicted of murdering his wife gruesomely with an axe.
Shaffer maintained that he was innocent throughout his trial, and even on his way to the gallows. Several appeals were made, which delayed his final sentence. Shaffer was held in a cell on the second floor of the 1818 jail during this time. Shortly before his execution was to take place in April of 1879, Shaffer tried to commit suicide with a knife.
The Sheriff's little daughter had found him covered in blood when she kindly went to give him some Easter eggs. A doctor was summoned quickly and Shaffer survived the attempt, but inquests were made as to whether he was sane and therefore could be executed for murder. The final decision was made by the Governor of Pennsylvania, and the execution proceeded on a bleak rainy day, April 17, 1879.
A gallows was constructed in the yard behind the jail, but Shaffer's suffering did not end quickly. The man was still so weak from his suicide attempt that he had to be carried to the gallows in a chair. Then it turned out that the gallows was not built properly, and the prisoner died a slow, suffocating death by strangulation rather than a quick, clean snap of the neck.
The body was placed in a coffin and per newspaper accounts remained in a corridor in the jail for many hours and was then taken to a pauper's grave at the County Almshouse.
Does Hezekiah Shaffer's troubled spirit still haunt the Old Jail? We don't know, but it may be so.
This post is part of our "Creepy Stories from Franklin County History" series in October.
Halloween is fast approaching! If you would like to take a tour of the Old Jail this Saturday, October 31, use our scheduling app or call to reserve your spot as soon as possible. We only offer guided tours.
Adults $5, children 7-17 $4, family rates available. We accept cash and cards. Guests and staff will be required to wear masks during your visit.
Our gift shop is open to walk ins, no appointment necessary.
Library visits are also by appointment only.
Scheduling app: franklinhistorical.org
717-264-1667
175 East King Street, Chambersburg

Comments
Post a Comment
We can do better!